A viral political claim raced across social media: Democratic U.S. Senate nominee James Talarico had received treatment at an Ohio mental health facility.
The claim was false.
The Lindner Center of Hope said Talarico had never received treatment there. Talarico said he had never been to Ohio. The Associated Press found that the timeline and images from the relevant period did not support the claim.
That correction is not a victory for the left. It is a test of whether conservatives value truth enough to protect our own credibility.
In this week’s Politics with the Big Dogs, Current Revolt publisher Tony Ortiz joins me to reconstruct how the story spread, explain what the full phone call contained and examine the cost of turning a weak claim into a national political distraction.
The viral post relied on a short excerpt from a phone call to the Ohio facility.
Tony obtained the full call. In that longer recording, the employee repeatedly said there was no patient by Talarico’s name. Near the end of the call, after the caller continued pressing, the employee suggested he might have checked out. That final statement became the viral clip.
It did not establish that Talarico had been a patient.
The facility later removed any remaining ambiguity by stating that Talarico had never received treatment there.
The issue is not whether any person should seek mental health care. There is no shame in getting help. The issue is whether the political claim was true.
It was not.
My concern extends beyond one bad story.
Talarico has a legislative record. Conservatives have serious disagreements with his positions on taxes, parental authority, education and government power. Those arguments should be made directly and supported with evidence.
When Republicans promote a claim that falls apart, we hand our opponents an easy response to every legitimate criticism that follows.
“We’ve eroded our own credibility,” I said in the episode.
A movement that wants voters to trust it with government power must first show that it can be trusted with the facts.
The conversation then turns to the Nov. 3 election.
Tony expects Republican Ken Paxton to defeat Talarico, although he believes the margin could be closer than Republicans have grown accustomed to seeing in a statewide race. He also notes that some political professionals he speaks with are more optimistic about Republican numbers than he is.
Those are predictions, not results. The latest UT/Texas Politics Project poll showed several statewide contests within the margin of error, including the Paxton-Talarico and Abbott-Hinojosa races.
We also examine several contests farther down the ballot:
Campaigns at the top of the ticket affect every Republican and Democrat beneath them. Nobody gets to skip the work.
Current Revolt has also examined the Texas Education Freedom Accounts marketplace, which is managed by Odyssey.
Approved expenses include bilingual classes, taekwondo lessons, pilot-training books and musical instruments. Those examples do not establish fraud or misuse. They do raise policy questions about how the state defines an educational expense, how vendors are approved and whether one program administrator should control the marketplace through which families spend public funds.
More than 274,000 applications were submitted, and more than 100,000 awards were made in the program’s first year. The initial appropriation was $1 billion for the 2026-27 school year.
I support educational competition and parental choice. Tony is more skeptical of the program. We agree on one essential point: Families and taxpayers deserve a clear system that produces better education.
“If it’s a good policy and a good program, we ought to open it up for everybody,” I said.
The final segment turns from political credibility to government surveillance.
In 2023, Texas lawmakers raised a motor-vehicle insurance fee by $1 to combat catalytic-converter theft. The Texas Tribune later reported that at least $30 million from the program helped fund at least 3,200 Flock cameras across the state.
Abbott’s office announced an Aug. 28 pause in state funding for local Flock camera grants.
On Oct. 13, Comptroller Don Huffines issued an order prohibiting all future grants administered by his office from being used to purchase or contract for Flock cameras, automated license plate readers and related vehicle-identification systems.
The order does not remove cameras already operating across Texas. It does not ban local governments from using other funds to purchase the technology. It does stop future comptroller-administered grants from financing those systems.
I support the action and ask a direct question: Why should Texans pay a state fee that helps local governments build searchable records of where Texans drive?
Law enforcement agencies point to stolen-vehicle recoveries, missing-person cases and violent-crime investigations as legitimate uses of automated license plate readers. The constitutional questions concern warrants, retention, access, audits and data sharing.
Security is not a blank check.
Huffines’ order is an example of a measurable policy outcome.
Republican leaders should be judged by the same standard across state government: Did the policy lower a tax bill? Did it protect a constitutional right? Did it improve a school? Did it make government smaller, more transparent or more accountable?
That standard also shapes my criticism of Gov. Greg Abbott.
I praise Abbott where I believe the governor has acted correctly. I also believe too many major announcements have failed to produce the results promised to working Texans, particularly on property taxes, insurance costs, electricity and the growth of state government.
The Texas Business Court deserves the same factual precision I demand elsewhere. It is not a court solely for insurance companies. It generally has concurrent jurisdiction with district courts over listed business disputes worth at least $5 million, and claims concerning duties under an insurance policy are excluded. Its judges are appointed by the governor, confirmed by the Senate and serve two-year terms. Abbott reappointed 10 judges in July.
My concern is the structure: Are short terms and executive appointments the right model for judges deciding consequential business disputes?
That is a debate worth having on the facts.
Texas voters will decide the races discussed in this episode on Tuesday, Nov. 3.
Early voting begins Monday, Oct. 19 and continues through Friday, Oct. 30. Polls are open from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. on Election Day.
Verify your registration, polling location and election information through VoteTexas: https://www.votetexas.gov/
Watch the full episode, then tell me which measurable result you want from the next Texas Legislature.
Anthony and Tony Ortiz examine what went wrong, who failed to see it coming and whether Texas Republicans are prepared to earn voters’ trust again.
Texas conservatives must vote now, then demand answers from Greg Abbott on data centers, electricity, taxes and accountability.
Examining Sid Miller's break with Greg Abbott over Texas data centers, emergency powers, the Bush-Talarico split and Hezbollah.